Is there space for an ultra-specialty coffee segment?
Estimated reading time: 8 minutes
Key takeaways
- Rising green coffee and operating costs have strained specialty roasters’ margins.
- Mid-range 85-point coffees face the tightest squeeze in specialty coffee.
- High-end professionals want an ultra specialty segment separate from mid-range coffee.
- Exceptional coffees still need skilled service to justify premium prices.
Specialty coffee has long rested on a simple promise: paying more buys better coffee. For many roasters, however, that promise is becoming harder to keep. Green coffee costs more, operating costs have climbed, and the margin that once funded premium sourcing has narrowed.
At Beantropy, held in Paris, France, on 30 July 2026, a talk on these pressures argued that the industry is heading towards a divide. In response, several high-end specialty professionals called for a new category altogether: an ultra-specialty segment that would separate the very top of the market from mid-range specialty. But whether this market is viable for producers remains in question.
You may also like our article on why micro lots get the glory but blends build loyalty.

Specialty coffee’s middle ground comes under pressure
For years, specialty coffee worked on a fairly simple model. Roasters paid a premium above the commodity price to buy high-quality, traceable coffee, and producers had a reason to grow and process it carefully. Many roasters built their brands on this, with some committing to pay 30% to 40% more than the market price. Coffees scoring around 85 points formed the core of most roasters’ offerings.
However, this model is harder to apply in today’s market. Many of those commitments were made when prices sat at historic lows. Over the same period, energy costs, unfavourable exchange rates, and broader inflation pushed up the cost of running a roastery, squeezing margins.
At the same time, exceptional coffees have become harder to secure. Producing top lots requires investment in advanced processing, quality laboratories, specialised drying infrastructure, and staff training. Producers who already earn high prices are best placed to make that investment, while many others lack the finance or market access to do so. As a result, roasters can no longer rely on a modest premium to buy outstanding coffee.
A market moving in two directions
The squeeze is tightest in the middle. An 85-point coffee now costs too much to compete on price with commercial coffee, yet it often lacks the distinction to justify a top-tier premium.
“For now, the market is pushing in two opposite directions,” says Christophe Servell, founder of Paris-based roaster and café group Terres de Café. “Down, with what I would call ‘fake’ specialty coffee: 80 to 83 points, coming from conventional and agribusiness practices, and now served in a lot of new-wave coffee shops that have to face up to their business model and profitability. On the other side, the emerging market of ultra specialty.
“The heart of specialty for me, 84 to 87 points, is starting to come under pressure because of the growing and more mature market and, most importantly, global warming and climate change,” he adds. “The next two years will be critical, I think, especially with the El Niño phenomenon.”
This points to a growing divide in the industry. On one side, larger roasters serve mid-range and entry-level specialty at scale. On the other, a small group of roasters and producers position themselves as the best of the best, built around auction lots, rare varieties, and competition coffees.

Is there space for an ultra specialty segment?
Several high-end specialty professionals now argue that the top of the market needs to separate itself from mid-range specialty. In their view, the best coffees need their own category, distinct from the specialty that larger roasters now sell at scale.
Defining the segment is the first challenge. It could rest on cupping scores, the rarity of a species or variety, processing methods, traceability, price thresholds, or a combination of these.
The top end of the market moves quickly. Gesha, once the benchmark for rarity, now appears on the menus of many high-end cafés, while competitors have turned to eugenioides, Sidra, Pink Bourbon, and Wush Wush. As a result, any definition based on variety alone would need constant revision.
Christophe’s definition rests on score, traceability, sustainability, and the reputation of the producer. “90+ coffee, ultra traceable, ultra sustainable,” he says. “Ultra specialty coffee can be defined as the absolute pinnacle of premium coffee: the rarest beans, sourced from the star farms of the coffee world.”
These coffees, he adds, come from producers “who have become or will become legends in the specialty industry”. “These individuals are highly decorated winners of major competitions, drawing throngs of enthusiasts to festivals, conferences, and congresses,” he says. “Our mission is to promote their work and find tomorrow’s legends.”
Christophe compares this tier to French wine, citing names such as Romanée-Conti, Coche-Dury, La Grange des Pères, Château Rayas, Haut-Brion, Yquem, Cheval Blanc, and Pétrus. “They enjoy a worldwide reputation and are often sold via allocations, purchased even before they are produced,” he says.
Securing supply and finding customers
Securing supply is the second challenge. Many of these varieties are difficult to scale; Sidra, for example, needs full shade and is vulnerable to pests and disease. Even so, Christophe sees more producers moving in this direction. “A lot of producers are now starting to produce ultra specialty, inspired by Panamanian producers’ practices and by market demand,” he says.
Ultra specialty depends on producers continuing to invest in exceptional lots, so it must offer them a clear and dependable financial incentive. Direct, long-term partnerships between producers and roasters could provide that, alongside importers who take on some of the risk of developing new suppliers.
“For me, a long-term relationship is based on time, of course, and our commitment to buy coffee every year, even if the crop is disappointing, but also on volumes and quality,” Christophe says. “In general, a producer can’t live on ultra specialty production alone, so we buy coffee for our different ranges: 80+, 85+, 88+ and Légendes. That way, the producer can expect substantial revenues that allow them to invest in sustainability, quality, and purchasing new land to increase their production.”
Finding the customer is the third. Ultra specialty coffees need buyers willing to pay far more, whether through cafés, retail bags, subscriptions, or competitions. Evidence suggests this audience exists, but it remains small. The SCA projected that roasted coffee sales would pass US$192 billion by the end of 2023, with 52% of that growth driven by premiumisation.

Exceptional coffee or exceptional service?
There are two competing visions for the future of high-end specialty. The first holds that specialty’s future lies in high-end customer service paired with great coffee. The ultra specialty group rejects this, arguing that the coffee itself must stay at the centre and that only the best lots can justify the price.
Both positions respond to the same pressure. With costs rising, roasters and cafés need a clear reason for customers to pay more, whether that reason is the experience or the coffee itself.
In practice, the two approaches overlap more than they first appear. A handful of coffee shops offer pour overs for US$20 or more, and only a small share of customers order the most expensive options. Selling them depends on trained baristas, consistent brewing, and storytelling about the farm, variety, and process. Exceptional coffees, in other words, often need exceptional service to communicate their value.
Christophe also links the two. “I think that ultra specialty coffee deserves ultra special places to be appreciated at their true value,” he says. In December, he plans to open The Légendes Shop in Paris, which he describes as “entirely dedicated to ultra specialty coffee, with a high level of hospitality and service.”
Service also accounts for a large part of the price of a premium cup. “On average, 30% goes to the producers, 20% is shipping, roasting, packaging, delivery, and other supply costs, and 50% is the service and margin,” Christophe says of a cup priced at US$20 or more. “Contrary to what one might assume, profit margins are lower than those seen in the specialty sector, and significantly lower than those in the agri-food industry.”

For roasters and café owners, the key decision is where to position themselves: mid-range specialty at scale, an ultra specialty offering, a service-led model, or a mix of these. Premium lots work best alongside a strong core menu rather than replacing it.
Whatever the choice, the gap between the middle and the top of specialty looks set to keep widening.
Interested in making more sales? PDG Media specialises in growing sales for coffee businesses. Check them out here.
Ultra specialty coffee FAQs
What is ultra specialty coffee?
Ultra specialty is a proposed category for the very top of the specialty coffee market. It could cover auction-winning lots, rare species and varieties, and competition coffees, defined by cupping scores, traceability, processing, or price. No formal definition exists yet.
Why are 85-point coffees under the most pressure?
Higher green coffee prices and operating costs mean 85-point coffees now cost too much to compete with commercial coffee on price. However, they often lack the distinction needed to justify the premiums that rare or auction-winning lots command.
Should cafés focus on better coffee or better service?
Most cafés need both. Rare, expensive coffees rely on trained baristas and clear storytelling to explain their value, while high-end service needs a product that justifies the price. Premium lots work best alongside a strong core menu.
Photo credits: Beantropy
Perfect Daily Grind
Want to read more articles like this? Sign up for our newsletter!




