Why removing crema from espresso is dividing specialty coffee
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
Key takeaways
- Crema signals freshness and quality in espresso, but it doesn’t reliably measure either.
- Removing crema can give a cleaner, sweeter, less bitter espresso with cleaner flavours.
- Crema also increases body and aroma release, so skimming it creates a trade-off.
- The best choice depends on the coffee, the roast profile, and personal preference.
Crema is the first thing most people notice in an espresso. The thick foam signals freshness, quality, and skill, and it has shaped what many expect from a shot since its invention in the 1940s.
But more coffee professionals are starting to question whether crema hinders the espresso sensory experience, rather than enhancing it. The debate isn’t new; James Hoffmann called crema “rubbish” in 2009, and some have advocated skimming it from espresso to minimise bitterness for years.
Recent discourse, however, shows that many are still divided on the practice, claiming we’re removing the “best part” of espresso.
Ultimately, the division highlights an underlying tension in specialty coffee: are we too concerned with reinventing classics or should we pursue new ways to experience espresso?
You may also like our article on why pre-batched espresso is so divisive.

What makes crema so special?
For decades, crema has been one of espresso’s most recognisable characteristics. The reddish-brown foam on a freshly extracted shot is most closely associated with classic Italian espresso and, for many consumers, remains a familiar indicator of freshness and quality.
Crema forms when carbon dioxide trapped inside roasted coffee dissolves into water under the high pressure of espresso extraction. As the liquid returns to atmospheric pressure, the gas escapes as tiny bubbles, stabilised by surfactants such as coffee oils, carbohydrates, and melanoidins.
Its role in the cup isn’t purely aesthetic. Crema contributes body and texture, affects aroma release, and can offer clues about freshness and extraction. However, it’s not a reliable measure of quality on its own. Roast profile, age, and brewing parameters can all change how much crema the coffee forms.
It also shapes perceptions around quality. Research found that crema increased consumer expectations that an espresso would be higher quality, smoother, and more premium-tasting.
Increasingly, however, some specialty coffee professionals are challenging these long-held assumptions and asking the question: does espresso actually taste better without it?
Michael Harris Conlin, three-time Philippine Barista Champion and CEO of Global Coffee Awards Asia Gold winner Henry and Sons, explored this while preparing for competition. His espresso used a blend of liberica and eugenoides, which can increase bitterness.
“During one of the many espresso cupping sessions, we tried removing the crema with a spoon and found that it greatly improved the tactile experience and taste balance of our blend,” he says.
This experiment led Michael and his son Liam to develop the Better Vessel, a post-extraction tool designed to separate the crema from brewed espresso. Michael introduced it during his 2025 World Barista Championship routine, where his espresso received the highest score in the first round.

Sacrilegious or expanding the barista’s toolkit?
There is a sensory scientific argument for both sides of the fence.
Crema contains carbon dioxide, emulsified oils, and suspended coffee particles. Tasted on its own, it’s often notably bitter with a drying texture. Removing it can therefore reduce this and change how sweetness, acidity, and more delicate flavour notes are perceived.
“Without the layer of crema dominating the experience, I often perceive the espresso as cleaner and less bitter, with greater flavour clarity,” Michael says. “Flavour notes can become easier to recognise, and the finish can feel more pleasant and less drying.”
He also finds that removing crema changes texture, making some shots feel “smoother and juicier”.
Yet crema is doing useful work, too. Research has found that it can influence the retention and release of volatile aromatic compounds. One sensory study found that a standard amount of crema supported the release of pleasant volatile compounds, while larger quantities were associated with a stronger roasted sensory experience. Filtering crema minimised this effect, but also reduced the release of some aroma compounds.
In other words, removing crema isn’t always a straightforward upgrade; it can be a trade-off. The ideal balance of flavour, texture, and aftertaste will vary from coffee to coffee. Crema can add body, texture, and bitterness that help round out an espresso, while some coffees may benefit more from the increased clarity removing it can bring.
Even when Coffee Collective was experimenting with skimming crema from espresso as far back as 2008, they reported a cleaner and less bitter cup, but also the loss of body, which is vital for excellent espresso.
This is also why stirring is considered useful. Crema’s bitterness may taste unpleasant in isolation, but mixing it through the espresso can integrate it with sweetness and acidity rather than removing it altogether.

The crema debate won’t be settled
Crema removal is also overlapping with other practices in espresso preparation. Beta Coffee in Sydney, Australia says pre-batching espresso has allowed them to skim crema and filter fines from shots for higher clarity, contributing to a sweeter cup.
Ultimately, this points to a broader willingness within specialty coffee to question long-established conventions. Turbo shots challenged traditional espresso recipes, extract chilling changed how competitors approached temperature and aroma and, more recently, pre-batched and ultrasonic espresso have pushed the beverage further from its Italian roots.
Removing crema is particularly contentious because it’s not simply a brewing variable; it’s woven into espresso’s identity. For some drinkers, removing it takes away the bitterness that obscures the coffee’s intrinsic flavour. For others, bitterness and texture are integral to a balanced experience.
Michael doesn’t frame the Better Vessel as the correct way to serve every shot.
“It isn’t saying everyone should remove crema,” he says. “It’s about questioning something we’ve accepted for a very long time and giving people a new way to enjoy espresso.”
Perhaps the most useful approach to this new variable is the simplest: taste the same espresso in three different ways. Try it untouched, try it with the crema stirred through the liquid to integrate its bitterness with the rest of the shot, and then try it removed entirely. For baristas and consumers, this could become a useful sensory exercise for exploring how aroma, bitterness, texture, and flavour clarity interact.

As specialty coffee continues to deconstruct espresso in search of new sensory experiences, whether crema stays or goes should depend on the coffee in the cup and the experience the barista wants to create.
The evidence doesn’t point to a single right answer, because the best choice depends on the coffee, the roast profile, and the consumer. Lighter roasts may benefit from the increased bitterness, while other coffees may taste better without crema. In specialty coffee, it should be a matter of preference, not gospel.
Need more leads for your coffee business? Get in touch with PDG Media, our marketing agency dedicated to specialty coffee, here.
Removing crema espresso FAQs
What is crema?
Crema is the reddish-brown foam on top of a freshly pulled espresso. It forms when water at up to nine bars of pressure dissolves carbon dioxide from roasted beans, and the gas escapes as tiny bubbles when the liquid leaves the portafilter.
Does removing crema make espresso taste better?
Michael Harris Conlin, three-time Philippine Barista Champion, says it can. Without crema, he finds espresso cleaner, less bitter, less drying, and with clearer flavours. The foam binds small particles, oils and sometimes ash, which add bitterness. Results vary by coffee, so taste both versions and decide.
Does crema show that a coffee is fresh or well made?
Partly. Fresher coffee produces more crema, and a thin layer can point to channelling during extraction. However, avoid judging a coffee by its crema alone, and light roasts typically produce very little.
Enjoyed this? Then read our article on ultrasonic espresso.
Photo credit: Bianca Marvida
Perfect Daily Grind
Want to read more articles like this? Sign up for our newsletter!





