ICP calls for further delays to EUDR: Is the coffee industry ready?
The conversation about the upcoming European Union Deforestation Regulation (or EUDR) is clearly ongoing in the coffee industry. Not only are EU traders and roasters keen to understand more about how they can successfully comply with new regulations, they have also voiced their concerns about how the bill has been implemented.
On 5 June 2024, members of International Coffee Partners – including key industry players like Lavazza, Löfbergs, Neumann Kaffee Gruppe, and Tchibo – penned an open letter to EU policy makers to call for further delays to the EUDR deadline. ICP members’ concerns largely stem from their belief that smallholder farmers haven’t received enough support or information to comply with the strict requirements, and therefore they risk being excluded from the EU market.
Considering that smallholders grow up to a staggering 80% of the world’s coffee supply, these apprehensions are certainly warranted. To learn more, I spoke to Marcel Starfinger, Sustainable Business Unit Programme Manager at Neumann Kaffee Gruppe.
You may also like our article on how roasters can successfully comply with EUDR.

The industry voices further concerns about EUDR
The EUDR has been a hot topic for some time now. Essentially, the new regulations require producers, traders, and roasters to prove that their EU coffee shipments are part of deforestation-free supply chains by the end of December 2024. If not, they will lose access to one of the biggest and most important coffee markets in the world, risk having their shipments taken from them, and may even have to pay non-compliance fees.
While many support the overall objective of the bill (which is to effectively minimise and eradicate deforestation in a number of supply chains), there has been significant criticism of its implementation so far.
In response, the EU delayed the compliance deadline for smaller-sized companies to the end of June 2025. But understandable concerns still persist, including from key players in the market.
Members of International Coffee Partners (ICP) – a consortium of leading companies focused on improving smallholders’ market access – have voiced their apprehension about how these producers will be able to meet the EUDR deadline.
Marcel Starfinger is the Sustainable Business Unit Programme Manager at Neumann Kaffee Gruppe, a multinational green coffee trader and ICP member.
“The uncertainties created by EUDR are to smallholders’ detriment, and have already led to shifts in demand,” he says. “In the most recent harvest, for example, Ethiopia experienced strongly slowed demand from Europe.
“Given that countries have different risk factors associated with deforestation, certain ones may see increasing demand from Europe, while others will see declines,” he adds. “Whether this leads to economic losses or gains depends on the availability of other existing market outlets. However, we expect that producers in more complex and informal supply chains will feel the impact more.”
Why are smallholder producers at more risk?
The term “smallholder” typically refers to producers who grow coffee on an area five hectares or smaller. Despite their significantly smaller production volumes, these farmers grow most of the world’s coffee – making them incredibly valuable to the global market.
As a result of these much lower yields, however, an estimated 5.5 million smallholders live below the international poverty line of US $3.20 per day. This means they often have little to no capital to invest back into their farms, which now includes paying for data and information to prove they are in compliance with EUDR if they sell to European traders and roasters.
“In a risk assessment, any coffee coming from countries that flag a high-risk of deforestation require cost-intensive traceability and monitoring systems to prove compliance,” Marcel tells me. “It’s much cheaper and less risky under EUDR to source from larger farms located far away from forests than to engage in detailed mitigation measures.
“A second risk we identified is that EUDR requires a lot of paperwork, geodata, and evidence that shipments are deforestation-free and in compliance with national laws,” he adds. “The cost to purchase a GPS point or a polygon are similar whether you are a 0.5ha farm or a large estate. But per bag of coffee, this would only be 3% to 4% of total costs for an estate, and much more for a smallholder given the differences in production volumes.”

Why EUDR compliance is essential
Although the new bill is overwhelming for many, preparing to comply in time for the upcoming deadline is a must for any producer, trader, and roaster that operates in the EU market. If not, it’s likely we’ll see big shifts in demand – and smaller businesses and farms will feel the effects the most.
“Overall, Europe is likely to see more expensive coffees from less diverse origins, which reduces the variety of flavour and creates future supply risks, especially given climate change,” Marcel says. “Hold-ups and interim shortages could also occur following implementing new procedures before custom clearance. This is challenging under the short timeline given the remaining unclarities in the regulations.
“We are determined to implement the EUDR in a smallholder inclusive manner to keep them in EU supply chains and to provide a diversity of cup profiles to our customers,” he adds. “If smallholders are unable to comply, we fear that they will simply shift to non-EU market outlets. In the worst case, they might withdraw completely from coffee production or leave coffee-growing regions to look for work elsewhere.”
How EU roasters & traders can work with producers
For farms of any size, losing access to the EU coffee market is huge. The value of the European specialty coffee market is US $20.6 billion and accounts for 30% of the global market. But given that smallholders supply so much of the world’s coffee – and are some of the most economically vulnerable actors in the supply chain – maintaining their access is crucial.
The impact of seized shipments or hefty fines would also be detrimental to European roasters and traders. So it’s even more important that supply chain actors work together to understand how to comply with EUDR.
“While EU companies are directly affected by the regulation, a substantial share of the work needs to be done at origin,” Marcel says. “We remain convinced that coordinated pre-competitive industry-wide efforts will allow roasters and traders to comply in a resource-efficient manner.
“We do our part as a trader, yet we also rely on the commitment of our customers and other industry stakeholders to preserve the diversity of sourcing different origins and coffees from different-sized producers,” he adds. “Additionally, we rely on our sustainable sourcing schemes like NKG Verified and NKG Bloom to ensure that coffee remains an attractive and profitable crop for producers.”

Many key players in the global coffee sector have raised concerns about the upcoming EUDR deadline – especially regarding retaining smallholders’ access to the EU market. In line with this, it’s clear that industry stakeholders need to work together more effectively.
Collecting and sharing relevant data is the starting point, but collaboration extends much further beyond this. Building long-term and transparent relationships is now essential.
Enjoyed this? Then read our article on what the coffee industry can expect from EUDR delays.
Perfect Daily Grind
Want to read more articles like this? Sign up for our newsletter!




