Brewing great coffee means balancing many variables. As well as considering your brewing recipe, brew method, and ratio of coffee to water, you should keep your roast profile in mind.
Perhaps you have a go-to recipe for making an excellent V60. However, if you change from a light roast to medium, you may have to rethink it. Read on for some insights into how to adjust it for your coffee roast profile.
Coffee beans cooling down after being roasted
How Coffee Roast Profiles Vary
Roasted coffee is generally divided into light, medium, and dark. You likely have a go-to roast profile that you prefer for a brewing recipe. But what’s the real difference between them?
There’s no industry standard for light, medium, or dark roasters often use their own names for different profiles. Generally, light roasts retain more of the coffee’s flavours, emphasising floral and citrus notes. Darker roasters roasted overwhelm these subtle flavours with chocolatey, nutty sensations. If a very dark roast can become bitter.
Flavour isn’t the only difference among roast profiles. The more heat a coffee is exposed to in a longer or hotter roast, the more porous and soluble it becomes. It’s partly why we use medium or dark roast coffees to make espresso. Because there’s only a short window of time for extraction, a soluble roast will work better than a light roast.
Roasted coffee beans in a bag.
Why Should You Brew Light & Dark Roasts Differently?
A good cup of coffee depends on having the correct extraction levels. When you introduce coffee beans to water, it extracts a number of their chemical compounds. The compounds responsible for fruity notes and acidity are extracted first. It then extracts sugars to produce sweet flavours, and then the compounds that create bitterness. Underextracted coffee can taste sour because the sugars haven’t yet extracted, and overextracted coffee can be bitter. This will impact your brewing recipe.
Because light roasts are less porous than darker ones, their compounds extract more slowly. It’s why light roasts are often brewed slowly using a pour over – the beans have more time in the water than in a quick brewing method such as espresso. It also means that if you use the same brewing recipe and coffee but two different roast profiles, you’d experience different flavours and mouthfeel.
Sam Koh is a barista and the founder of Kaffiend Brews, a coffee shop in Singapore. She tells me that “a light roasted coffee gives you more intricate notes, and these can be best accentuated through a slower brew such as a pour over. A darker roast may not shine through a slower brew due to its extraction rate, creating more acrid or bitter notes.”
Roasted beans in a cup.
How to Tweak Your Brew Recipe For a Different Roast Profile
So, you have a brewing recipe figured out but want to try new beans. How can you adjust your method to fit a different roast profile? To compensate for differences in porosity and solubility, you can change a few variables.
When coffee is ground finer, it has more surface exposure. This means that extraction will happen more quickly. So if you’re used to brewing with a medium roast and are trying out a light roast, grind it a little finer. Likewise, if you usually use light-roasted beans, but are going darker, use a coarser grind size.
Marlous Van Putten is a store manager and barista with Dutch coffee shop chain Coffeecompany. She says, “I personally also always grind my beans finer if they’re a lighter roast and dark roasts on the coarser side. This is because dark roast tends to be more bitter in flavour to begin with, so a longer contact time between water and coffee would result in over extraction.”
Freshly ground coffee beans are poured into a Chemex.
There is no one correct temperature for brewing coffee (although there are recommended ranges, such as the SCA’s suggestion of 195–205 °F/90–96°C). But the hotter the water used, the faster the extraction. Some compounds will never be extracted at very low temperatures, which is why cold brew tends to be very mellow and sweet but can lack any bitterness to balance out other notes.
Consider water temperature as one more factor you can adjust to bring out your preferred flavours in your coffee when using a specific brewing recipe. If you’re using a dark roast, you may want to lower the temperature of the water to avoid over-extraction and reduce the chance of bitter flavours. If you’re using a lighter roast than usual, using hotter water will help speed up extraction a little.
Marlous says, “The normal rule is lower temperatures for darker roasts and higher temperatures for lighter roasts. Side note to this is that darker roast probably won’t taste good if it’s made with water at high temperatures, whereas lighter roast can taste good made with lower temperatures.”
You may also like our article on why thermal stability is important for manual coffee brewing.
Coffee brews in a Chemex.
The longer the coffee is exposed to water, the more time there is for extraction to take place. Keep this in mind when choosing a brewing method – as discussed, espresso only has a very short opportunity to extract so a light roast might not be the best choice.
Within each brewing method, you can also tweak your technique to provide a longer or shorter brewing time. For example, by pouring water more slowly when making filter coffee, or by letting a French press sit for longer before serving.
Sam says, “For coffee that is of a lighter roast, I find that letting it steep longer before first drip gives the coffee more time to exude more complex and intricate flavors.”
Coffee being brewed on a Chemex.
Other Factors That Could Impact Your Brew Recipe
It can be interesting to use different roast profiles with various grind sizes, water temperature, and brewing time and see how these variables impact your cup. But you should also consider what features can change accidentally with your brewing recipe.
As coffee beans age, flavour degrades. Oxidation and degassing cause the coffee to lose the important oils and compounds that contribute to body, aroma, and flavour. It’s generally recommended to use roasted coffee beans within two weeks after buying them, to store them in air- and light-tight containers, and to grind them as needed to avoid even faster oxidation.
Coffee beans being weighed on a scale before brewing.
If you know your beans are a little old, you can adjust the brewing recipe to compensate. By grinding light roasts finer, you’ll increase the surface area and the rate of extraction, which should liven up slightly stale beans.
Old dark roasted beans can be very porous and therefore very soluble. Grinding a little coarser or using cooler water will slow down extraction and avoid the brew becoming too bitter.
Marlous recommends keeping in mind a few other factors that may make or break your end result. “What kind of water you use, the freshness of the beans, the quality of the beans, the cleanness of your equipment,” she says. “You have to be aware that every step of the process has an effect on the outcome of the cup.”
Freshly ground coffee.
Perhaps you have a brewing recipe that you’ve developed through controlled experiments or trial and error. But when you try a new roast profile or beans from a different roaster, it’s time to rethink your method. By understanding how variables including grind size, brewing time, and water temperature can be adjusted, you can get great results with every roast profile.
Enjoyed this? You may also like our article on whether we need to rethink the relationship between grind size and coffee extraction.
Perfect Daily Grind
Want to read more articles like this? Sign up for our newsletter!